By: Seth A. Robbins, Esq.
Published: October 2026
Practice Areas: Commercial Civil Litigation | Real Estate & Construction Litigation | Government Contracts
Industry Summary
- The Issue: Shopping centers are implementing youth supervision policies in response to safety and security concerns, potentially affecting customer access and tenant revenue.
- Contractual Risk: Landlords’ authority to regulate common areas and impose security measures must be considered alongside the terms of their commercial leases and the rights of their tenants.
- Financial Exposure: Restrictions affecting customer access may lead to lost sales, disputes over recoverable damages, and questions about insurance coverage.
- Key Consideration: Commercial landlords and tenants should evaluate how their lease agreements allocate the risks associated with access restrictions, changes to shopping center policies, and resulting business losses.
Understanding the Legal and Business Implications of Youth Supervision Policies
In September 2026, Westfield Wheaton and Westfield Montgomery in Maryland announced new parental supervision policies requiring visitors under 18 to be accompanied by an adult aged 21 or older after 3 p.m. daily. Similar restrictions have been adopted at other shopping centers in the region, including Arundel Mills in Maryland and Stonebridge at Potomac Town Center in Woodbridge, Virginia. (Read more about the Westfield policies).
These policies reflect a growing response to so-called “teen takeovers”—large gatherings of teenagers, often organized through social media, that have raised safety and security concerns. While intended to protect shopping centers and their patrons, these restrictions can also have significant legal and financial consequences for businesses operating within those properties.
For commercial landlords and tenants, the issue extends beyond whether a landlord has the authority to impose such restrictions. What happens when a policy designed to protect a shopping center substantially interferes with a tenant’s business and its ability to serve customers?
The answer may depend on the lease language, the circumstances surrounding the restriction, the applicable law, and the financial consequences for the affected business.
What Does the Lease Permit?
Commercial leases frequently give landlords broad authority to establish rules governing common areas, security, and access to shopping centers. However, that authority must be considered alongside the landlord’s other contractual obligations and the tenant’s rights under the lease.
For example, a tenant may have leased space for a particular business with the expectation that its customers would have reasonable access to the premises during operating hours. A youth supervision policy that substantially restricts access to that business’s primary customer base may raise questions about whether the landlord has exceeded its contractual authority or interfered with the tenant’s rights under the lease.
Even where a lease expressly authorizes the landlord to adopt security measures and regulate common areas, that authority does not necessarily eliminate the tenant’s ability to challenge the manner in which those restrictions are imposed or enforced.
The analysis requires consideration of the entire lease, including provisions governing permitted use, customer access, common-area regulations, operating hours, landlord discretion, notice requirements, and the parties’ respective contractual obligations.
Applicable law may also differ depending on the property’s location. For example, commercial leasing disputes involving Maryland properties may require review of the Maryland Real Property Article, while disputes involving Virginia properties require consideration of Virginia law and applicable contract principles. Neither jurisdiction’s statutory provisions should be assumed to resolve a particular dispute without examining the facts and the lease itself.
Ultimately, the central question is whether the restriction falls within the landlord’s contractual authority and whether its implementation is consistent with the parties’ legal obligations.
Can a Tenant Recover Lost Sales or Profits?
Consider an entertainment venue that depends heavily on teenage customers. If a shopping center implements a policy restricting unaccompanied minors during peak business hours, the tenant may experience a substantial decline in revenue.
But does that decline give rise to a claim against the landlord?
Not necessarily. Even if the tenant can establish that the policy caused a reduction in sales, it must still identify a viable legal basis for recovery. The lease may contain limitations of liability, waivers of consequential damages, or other provisions restricting available remedies.
Proving damages presents another challenge. Lost revenue is not the same as lost profits, and a tenant generally must establish causation and the amount of recoverable damages with reasonable certainty. The analysis may require examining historical sales, operating expenses, customer traffic, seasonal patterns, and other factors that could have affected business performance.
The issue becomes particularly interesting when the lease includes percentage rent, under which the landlord receives a portion of the tenant’s gross sales. In that situation, a decline in revenue may financially affect both parties. Nevertheless, the landlord’s reduction in percentage rent does not necessarily compensate the tenant for lost profits or resolve the parties’ respective contractual rights.
For both parties, the practical lesson is to examine the lease’s remedies and damages provisions before assuming that a decline in sales will result in recoverable compensation.
Litigation, Risk Management, and Insurance
For landlords and tenants, these disputes underscore the importance of addressing potential restrictions and their financial consequences before they arise.
Landlords should review the scope of their contractual authority, applicable notice requirements, and provisions allocating responsibility for changes affecting customer access. They should also consider how proposed policies may affect different tenant categories and whether the restrictions can be implemented in a manner consistent with existing lease obligations.
Tenants, particularly those whose businesses depend on younger customers, should carefully consider these issues when negotiating or renewing leases. Provisions addressing access, common-area rules, changes to shopping center policies, operating requirements, and available remedies may become especially important when the tenant’s business model depends on a particular customer demographic.
Both parties should also evaluate available insurance coverage. Traditional business interruption insurance generally focuses on covered disruptions involving physical loss or damage, and declining revenue resulting solely from customer access restrictions may not qualify for coverage.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ guidance on business interruption insurance explains common coverage principles and the importance of policy terms. Actual coverage depends on the specific policy language, applicable exclusions, endorsements, and circumstances of the loss.
A tenant should not assume that a decline in customer traffic is insured simply because the business remains open but experiences reduced sales. Landlords and tenants should review their policies with their insurance professionals and legal counsel to determine whether any relevant coverage applies.
Key Takeaway for Commercial Landlords and Tenants
Youth supervision policies illustrate how a decision intended to address shopping center safety can create contractual and financial questions for businesses operating within the property.
The legal issue is not simply whether a landlord can implement a particular restriction. It is whether the restriction is consistent with the lease, how the resulting economic risks are allocated, and what remedies may be available if the policy materially affects a tenant’s business.
Landlords should understand the limits of their contractual authority before implementing significant access restrictions. Tenants should understand the rights and remedies available under their leases and evaluate how changes to shopping center policies could affect their operations.
For both parties, careful lease drafting, clear communication, and early legal review can help reduce uncertainty and minimize the risk of disputes.
Reference Materials & Agency Resources
- Westfield Mall Youth Supervision Policy: Coverage and Implementation Overview. Consult the applicable shopping center’s published policy for current terms and exceptions.
- Maryland General Assembly: Real Property Statutes
- Code of Virginia: Official Legislative Information
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners: Business Interruption & Business Owner Policy Guide
These materials are intended as starting points for further research and do not replace direct review of the applicable lease, insurance policy, and jurisdiction-specific legal authorities.
How RLG Law Can Help
RLG Law represents commercial landlords, tenants, and businesses in contract disputes, commercial litigation, and matters involving real estate and contractual risk allocation.
Our attorneys assist clients in evaluating commercial lease provisions, assessing contractual rights and potential damages, addressing disputes arising from changes in property policies, and managing legal risks before they escalate into litigation.
For commercial landlords and tenants facing questions about access restrictions, lease obligations, or business losses, early legal review can help clarify available options and identify practical steps to protect their interests.

About the Author
Seth A. Robbins, Esq. is the Founder and Principal Attorney at RLG Law (Robbins Law Group, PLLC). He represents commercial clients in contract disputes, real estate and construction litigation, and complex business matters across Virginia, Maryland, Washington, D.C., and West Virginia.
Email: srobbins@rlg.law
Phone: 703-579-9065
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice or the formation of an attorney-client relationship.